Cavallario's Bayside

3.9 ( 149 reviews )
$10–20
01 James St, Alexandria Bay, NY 13607, United States
+1 315-482-4438

Cavallario's Bayside, nestled at 01 James St, Alexandria Bay, offers a delightful blend of Italian charm and culinary excellence that keeps diners returning for more. Customers rave about the incredible pizza, citing not only its rich flavors but also the delightful gluten-free options that cater to a variety of dietary preferences.

With a user-friendly counter service model, guests place their orders and receive buzzers, making it a relaxed and efficient dining experience. The atmosphere is truly enchanting, with shaded deck seating that invites guests to enjoy meals while taking in stunning views of the Upper James Street docks.

Reviewers universally commend the warm hospitality provided by owners Pete and Brenda, who embody the spirit of traditional Italian service. Patrons also highlight a range of side options, including exceptional antipasto platters and desserts, amplifying their culinary experience. Jeremiah Maxon aptly sums it up: "Summer isn’t summer without a trip to eat pizza on the water at Cavallario's." With a perfect harmony of great food and breathtaking scenery, Cavallario's Bayside truly deserves its accolades as a must-visit in the heart of Alexandria Bay.

Amenities and More

  • Service options
    • Has outdoor seating
    • Offers kerbside pickup
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
    • No delivery
  • Offerings
    • Serves alcohol
    • Serves beer
    • Serves cocktails
    • Serves happy-hour food
    • Serves small plates
    • Serves vegetarian dishes
    • Serves wine
  • Dining options
    • Serves lunch
    • Serves dinner
    • Has counter service
    • Serves dessert
    • Has seating
  • Amenities
    • Has toilet
  • Crowd
    • Family friendly
  • Planning
    • Reservations required
  • Payments
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Credit cards
  • Children
    • Good for kids
    • High chairs available

Reviews For Cavallario's Bayside

Jared Howell
Jun 18,2025
Great place! Couldn’t have left happier, check them out if in the area
Ashlei Patterson
Jun 17,2025
Great pizza! You place your order at the counter and recieve a buzzer to be notified when your food is ready. Great dessert, sandwich, and salad options, and they're all very good (side options as well). We always come here for our meals when in the Bay. Inside seating available as well as deck shaded seating too with a great breeze.
Josephine Cavallario
May 22,2025
Just gonna let everyone know how amazing this place is! The pizza is Incredible The customer service between Brenda and Peter is what you would imagine traditional Italian would be! Also, their antipasto is the best I’ve ever had! Check it out! 10/10
JCvintage
May 19,2025
Just gonna let everyone know how amazing this place is! The pizza is Incredible The customer service between Brenda and Peter is what you would imagine traditional Italian would be! Also, their antipasto is the best I’ve ever had! Check it out! 10/10 ...
Jeremiah Maxon
May 16,2025
Summer isn't summer without a trip to eat pizza on the water at Cavallario's. Cavallario's is — hands down — the best restaurant in the bay. The location is right on the water with a fantastic view of the Upper James Street docks. Pete and Brenda are the nicest hosts and the food is fantastic, especially the gluten free pizza. We LOVE the new setup — grab a menu, seat yourself, and come to the counter to order and get a buzzer.
lee rushlow
May 13,2025
My favorite place to eat in the bay. Food is always fresh and authentic. Better than the other eateries downtown. Must trys include the meatball sandwich , the canoli, and dont skip the pizza. Its a scientifically proven fact there are no calories when youre on vacation !!
Jessica Casillo' Williams
May 6,2025
Nice bayside pizza place. Food was good. My husband and I got the super hoagie and shared. They run on a number system, so it's easy to here when your order is up too. Would go back again!
Paula Parker
Mar 13,2025
Loved the chicken wings and pizza was very good as well

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

Lazy Crab Tara Blvd
(1496 review)
Lazy Crab Tara Blvd
  • 6703 Tara Blvd, Jonesboro, GA 30236, United States
seafood restaurant
+1 678-519-5375
Taz Indian Cuisine Temple
(230 review)
Taz Indian Cuisine Temple
  • 7373 Honeysuckle #140, Temple, TX 76502, United States
indian restaurant
+1 254-231-3003
Hex & Company
(378 review)
Hex & Company
  • 1462 1st Ave, New York, NY 10075, United States
cafe
+1 646-833-7574
Twin Silos Restaurant @ Geneva Farm Golf Course
(288 review)
Twin Silos Restaurant @ Geneva Farm Golf Course
  • 217 Davis Rd, Street, MD 21154, United States
American restaurant
+1 410-452-8800
Muffins Cafe
(113 review)
Muffins Cafe
  • 9 High St, East Hoathly, Lewes BN8 6DR, United Kingdom
Cafe
+44 1825 840087
Gran Torino
(883 review)
Gran Torino
  • 131 Berry St, Brooklyn, NY 11249, United States
Restaurant
Pour Decisions
(237 review)
Pour Decisions
  • 2800 Bledsoe St # 200, Fort Worth, TX 76107, United States
Restaurant
+1 682-203-0726
Muffin Break Cardiff
(423 review)
Muffin Break Cardiff
  • Unit KLG12, St Davids Way, St Davids Centre, Cardiff CF10 2EF, United Kingdom
cafe
+44 29 2022 7252
Oishi Sushi Restaurant
(454 review)
Oishi Sushi Restaurant
  • 163 N Milwaukee Ave, Libertyville, IL 60048, United States
Sushi restaurant
+1 847-281-7818
Zuri Coffee
(138 review)
Zuri Coffee
  • 2218 Broadway, New York, NY 10024, United States
coffee shop